2025 Porsche 718 Cayman vs. 2025 Mercedes-Benz AMG C 43

Sports car enthusiasts in 2025 have plenty to get excited about with two standout options: the Porsche 718 Cayman and the Mercedes-AMG C 43. Each one appeals to drivers in different ways, with the Cayman focused on mid-engine handling precision and the C 43 offering sedan practicality paired with AMG performance DNA. Both vehicles stand strong in their respective categories, but the choice depends on whether you want sharp two-seat thrills or a powerful yet versatile daily driver.

Design & Style

Sculpted lines, low stance, and the unmistakable silhouette of a mid-engine coupe define the 718 Cayman. Its proportions favor agility and performance, with short overhangs and wide haunches that communicate its purpose. Every design cue draws attention to the car's balance between aerodynamics and visual appeal.

By contrast, the AMG C 43 adopts the four-door sedan format yet integrates distinct AMG elements. A bold front grille, quad exhaust outlets, and muscular side contours give it presence on the road. While more practical in nature, it maintains the aggressive styling that identifies it as part of AMG's performance lineup.

Technology & Safety

Clever use of technology sets the C 43 apart with its latest MBUX infotainment system. The addition of a 5G data module, a central safety airbag, and a wide array of driver assistance features enhances both connectivity and protection. Occupants also enjoy sedan comforts like generous digital displays and convenient controls.

The 718 Cayman, while more minimalistic, provides a cockpit centered on the driver. Controls are arranged to keep focus on the road, with crisp displays and high-quality materials emphasizing precision. Safety features meet modern standards, though its tech package is intentionally leaner to maintain the purist driving feel.

Performance

Under its sleek body, the Cayman delivers performance starting with a turbocharged flat-four producing 300 horsepower. Higher trims step up to naturally aspirated six-cylinders with nearly 400 horsepower. Acceleration feels immediate thanks to the mid-engine layout, and the handling rewards drivers who appreciate feedback and balance through corners.

The C 43 brings raw power with its turbocharged four-cylinder hybrid system producing 416 horsepower and 369 lb-ft of torque. All-wheel drive paired with a nine-speed transmission makes for confident acceleration in various conditions. While heavier than the Cayman, it benefits from traction and stability that make it an appealing option for everyday spirited driving.

The Bottom Line

Choosing between these two models comes down to lifestyle and driving philosophy. The Cayman excels for those who want a true sports car experience with no compromises on handling or driver engagement. Drivers seeking more practicality and advanced tech without sacrificing speed may find the AMG C 43 a stronger match.

Either way, both cars bring impressive performance and distinct appeal. One thrives on agility and focused design, the other on blending performance with daily usability. Each represents a different interpretation of driving excitement in 2025.

Schedule a Test Drive Today

Experiencing a sports car in person is the best way to understand its appeal. At Porsche Norwell, we invite you to schedule a test drive and explore the Porsche 718 Cayman for yourself. Our team is ready to guide you through the available trims, discuss financing, and arrange a hands-on drive that showcases its agility and precision.

We also provide a full suite of services to support your ownership experience. From factory-trained technicians in our service department to genuine parts and accessories, everything is designed to keep your Porsche performing at its peak. Contact us today and let us help you discover what sets the Cayman apart from the competition.